which book out of the twilight saga is your favorite?

i thought i would do a poll to see what is everyones favorite book out of the saga.

I like New moon the best. I'm not really sure why though. lol

I loved Eclipse, personally.

But i hated 90% of Breaking Dawn.

I liked Eclipse but not as well because it made me not like Jacob too well.
And yeah there were some things in breaking dawn I didn't like.

Jacob_Black wrote:I like New moon the best. I'm not really sure why though. lol

you probably liked it because there was more action with Jacob...lol... that's understandable, there's nothing wrong with that..

Remington_Cullen wrote:I loved Eclipse, personally.

But i hated 90% of Breaking Dawn.

i loved pretty much all of breaking dawn... and i loved eclipse myself.. but my favorite was twilight.. i wasn't the biggest fan of new moon until recently.. new moon was just soooo sad... and i missed edward..lol...

New Moon made me cry.

Then I got to live it out myself. I hated it.

And Breaking Dawn was annoying.. >.> Like, a lot of it was, anyway. Too fairytale.... With too much sex.


Buuut I loved Twilight. It could never be surpassed.

And Eclipse was good. And New Moon.. Despite the torment of losing Edward, was still pretty good. Mmhmm.

HAHA! New Moon, Eclipse, and half of Breaking Dawn (The Renesmee and Jacob part).. those are my favorite...wait only clips of Eclipse cause i hate the way she treats Jake in Eclipse *growls viciously*... lol but yeah =]

she does treat jacob bad in eclipse... you gotta feel bad for the poor dog... but he did try to kiss her, so in a way he kind of deserved some of the awfulness..

i guess that is understandable... what gets me i guess is that even then deep inside she kinda wanted it.... and i just understand where he's coming from... i have been put in that sort of position before... it sucks.. i am sympathetic on his behalf.

she could have wanted it.. and she did kind of lead him on, and then leave him hanging on the string to suffer.. i guess it was kind of selfish of her to do that to Jacob... i've never been in that position, so it's harder for me to relate to...